Samantha Judge, Aaron’s wife of three years, gave birth to a baby girl named Nora Rose on Jan. 27. On Feb. 5, Judge posted a photo on Instagram of little Nora’s feet when announcing the addition to his household, which includes his beloved dogs, Penny and Max. Judge says that he never changed a diaper before becoming a father.

On Feb. 27, Judge shared a photo on his Instagram stories of a little pink leather baseball glove with purple seams, a tribute to his newborn daughter. The glove is embroidered with the Yankees' interlocking "NY" logo in navy blue and his daughter's name, "Nora Rose," stitched in purple. Judge added a purple heart and rose emoji to the post.